By Andy Seidel
Earlier this week, I dissected the issue of the gigantic gap between the Eastern and Western Conferences and looked into both the staggering numbers behind it and the few ways in which the East had shown promise so far (namely tough, physical defense). Then on Tuesday, I looked ahead to forecast the Eastern Conference teams that could turn it around, make the playoffs and maybe even bring a little bit of respectability back to the East. The most common questions that came from readers of those articles were how did it get this bad and how does the East fix it?
The East has gotten where it is today through a series of conscious decisions, believe it or not. Some teams decided to mortgage the present ceiling of their teams for future benefit, while others took calculated gambles with the goal of winning now. Many of those gambles haven’t paid off, leading to the mess of mediocrity we have now. Before the season started, there were three perceived divisions of teams in the East that were far more relevant than the Atlantic, Midwest and Southeast Divisions: The Tankers (BOS, PHI, ORL, MIL), The Muddled Middle (DET, CLE, WAS, CHA, ATL, TOR) and The Supposed Contenders (MIA, IND, CHI, and possibly NYK & BKN).
The results, obviously, have instead left only two teams in The Contenders division. This past week, Washington has joined Atlanta and Chicago in the Muddled Middle division (and possibly Charlotte), but that’s about it. That leaves 10-11 teams in the Tankers division, even though more than half of those 11 have made it clear they want to win now and make the playoffs this year. Not a good sign when two of your supposed contenders have worse records than any of your supposed tankers, save Milwaukee.
This has resulted from poor personnel combinations and poor coaching so far in New York, Cleveland and Brooklyn, especially. These are the teams that have the talent to compete, but so far have done exactly the opposite (Side-note: The Brooklyn-NYK game last night was called a must-watch for all the wrong reasons, and it lived up to the billing. What an atrocity of a basketball game). Some of the others, such as Detroit, Toronto and Orlando, are still in the midst of figuring themselves out. Detroit for sure wants a playoff spot (and should get it) because of a draft pick related trade with Charlotte they made to get rid of Ben Gordon a few years back, but I think Toronto and Orlando are both heading the other direction, and fast. I expect Afflalo, DeRozan and Lowry all to be dealt sometime between Dec 15 and Feb 1st and for these teams to try and book it to the bottom of their respective divisions, which in Toronto’s case will be pretty hard.
However the differences in mindset between teams like Detroit/Cleveland and Toronto/Orlando isn’t a bad thing when you then consider two things: A) The Eastern Conference teams will all have to play 52 games against each other this season, which makes it easier for the teams that are trying to win now AND the teams that are trying to tank out to sort themselves out as the season progresses; and B) The more likely way to fix this conference disparity isn’t through a series of trades or free-agent signings, but the draft.
Several franchises have embraced this and are seriously looking at the benefits of starting fresh and trying to cultivate some in-house talent rather than gunning for aging or expensive free-agents. At the head of this pack are Philadelphia and Toronto, two forward thinking franchises lead by very smart people. They lead a coalition of four franchises that won’t fix the East this season, but just might be able to save it in the long run.
The Four Fixers:
1. Philadelphia 76ers – Sam Hinkie became a league darling on Draft Night 2013 when he shipped Jrue Holiday to the Pelicans for Nerlens Noel and a 2014 1st Round pick, a brilliant coup that got rid of a player who didn’t fit the analytics-based model Hinkie wanted to build on, brought in a guy with a very high defensive ceiling, and made a probabilistic, calculated bet on the odd roster construction of the Pelicans not working well.
With the unfortunate broken hand of Anthony Davis, I would say that the bet is almost certain to payoff. I had the Pelicans hovering around a 9-13% chance of a playoff spot before Davis’ injury. Now? I wouldn’t put it higher than 6% on my most optimistic model. The West is too tough. Philly’s collection of young, talented yet inexperienced players and league castaways helps to put them at a very high probability of snagging two lottery picks in a superbly talented draft.
That, coupled with probably letting Evan Turner walk for the sake of fit and future cap space, leaves them with Noel and two other future assets to pair with the so-far excellent Michael Carter-Williams as a core. Thad Young is a nice piece and Spencer Hawes is having a good season, but I get the feeling this team is building from their 2013 class of MCW and Noel forward, which bodes well given what we’ve seen out of the 2014 potential draftees so far in the college season. Couple that with their blistering league-leading pace so far and the great coaching of Brett Brown this season and this looks great for Hinkie’s 5-year plan. Cheers, Philly.
2. Toronto Raptors – Masai Ujiri inherited this island of misfit toys at the ideal moment. Rudy Gay is shooting the team out of contention on his own, while Kyle Lowry and Demar DeRozan are playing themselves into the position of being very movable pieces. Both have been solid-to-very good on a nightly basis this season, and neither is wildly overpaid the way that Gay is. Trading these two would leave you with a this-season core of the promising Valanciunas, advanced stats darling Amir Johnson, electrifying Terence Ross and Rudy Gay. That is a sub-35 win team if I’ve ever seen one, even in this year’s Eastern Conference. A lottery pick would be a reality for that team, and in this case, that would be an excellent prize.
I belive in Ujiri. I don’t think he’ll be able to move Gay this season, and that’s O.K. Instead, let him stink up the games and ban stat sheets from the locker room (and drive Dwayne Casey out of town in the process). That will drive you into a potentially very good-to-great draft pick and let you build around 2014 Prospect X, Valanciunas, Ross and Johnson. Considering Ujiri’s intelligence with fitting role players to a situation (See: Denver 2012-13) and his faith in pace and advanced metrics that becomes more important in this league each year, I think they have the look of a solid playoff team in 3-5 years. Get it done, T-Dot.
3. Boston Celtics – The Celtics began this process by cutting ties with franchise legends Paul Pierce and Kevin Garnett in June, continued it by hiring Brad Stevens to a 6-year contract that leaves plenty of room to stink for a few years, and just yesterday embraced Tankology 2013 yet again by announcing that Rajon Rondo will not be playing basketball again anytime soon. So far, this team has tanked at tanking (thanks a lot, Jared Sullinger) but they have learned a lot about their young players and their young coach in the process. This knowledge on it’s own will be a valuable asset going forward.
What’s more, the high minutes given to guys like Jordan Crawford, Avery Bradley, Brandon Bass and the aforementioned Sullinger make them more valuable in trade talks because they’ve kept the team relatively competitive despite never having been focal points of a professional team before. I fully expect this team to sell someone off before February to avoid any chance of making the playoffs.
If they will choose to keep Rondo to build around or mortgage him off for a future asset remains to be seen, but this team has set themselves up with a gluttony of draft picks in the coming years (2 first rounders in every year until 2019. Seriously.) courtesy of the Nets and Clippers.l. Those assets coupled with the young talent they are cultivating in players like Sullinger, Bradely and Olynyk, and they have far more of a future than a present. Celtic Pride never Dies, I put this team on the 5-year plan along with Philly and let it ride.
4. Orlando Magic – Somehow this team turned a disgruntled superstar who turned out to be in decline anyway into a young, skilled post guy and a probable All-Star and 22 point-per-game scorer in Nikola Vucevic and Arron Afflalo. They drafted and acquired a series of skilled, promising power forwards in Tobias Harris, Andrew Nicholson and Moe Harkless, and had Victor Oladipo fall into their laps because Cleveland had a bit too much faith in Dion Waiters. All of a sudden this team’s present outlook is actually not bad – which is why Afflalo is likely gone before the deadline.
Look, I’m all for teams trying to get playoff experience and the value that pride can bring to a franchise. But this team seriously might be one piece away from being able to home-grow a serious perennial playoff team! If they can lose some games fast by jettisoning Afflalo now and Big Baby and Jameer after the season, then they are left with a core of Harris/Harkless/Nicholson, Oladipo, Vucevic and 2014 Propsect Y. That plus a plethora future draft picks (Orlando has been brilliant about keeping them and stockpiling other teams such as Denver’s 2014 1st and the Lakers’ 2017 1st) and a very smart coach in Jacques Vaughn who has a proper long view perspective, and this team has both the right pieces and mentality to turn into a contender over the next decade. Be a leader, Orlando, not Afflalower.